Misfit Container

Sometimes there’s just more than can be contained.
(image by Ephraim Mayrena, via Unsplash)

I just finished a book that I wanted to like more than I did. I’ll have more to say about it over the next few days, so obviously it made me think, but maybe not exactly about what the author hoped I’d think about.

The book in question is Frivolity: A Defense, by Jehanne Dubrow. I was drawn to it because my writer friends are so, so serious (Hilton Als recently wrote about much of contemporary art as “grief porn”), and all I want to do is give people a good story that leaves them with something to think about afterwards. I think about writing a novel as being in the same category as making my friends a nice dinner, an analogy that infuriates one of my colleagues. So I wanted to read something that acknowledged the value of work that doesn’t see itself in conversation with a canon. (My canon, if I have one, is composed of paperback novels and TV sitcoms.)

I’ll talk more about the ideas of the book tomorrow. For today, I want to write about its most heartbreaking passage. I’d finished the book, and was browsing through its end matter. The Acknowlegements, the Notes, the Bibliography, the Index—all of the academic armor that turns a 119-page book into a 144-page book, that allows its publication by a university press, that gives its author further hold on the sheer walls of academia. The kind of stuff you’d never find in a novel, the kind of stuff that marks a book as “one of ours” if that’s the crowd you run with.

And the very last endnote, note 156 that clings to the final punctuation mark of the text, ends with this:

So, I’ll confess: If I could give myself a name, it might not be scholar. It might be epicure or enthusiast. It might be lover instead.

Ms. Dubrow, or perhaps more appropriately Dr. Dubrow, has found a container for her work that doesn’t actually hold the entirety of her work. She must be a Distinguished Research Professor, not an enthusiast. She works within an academic context that actively demeans frivolity, a context that demands “rigor” and “advancement of the discipline” and looks at pleasure (“mere” pleasure) with suspicion.

When I was at Bread Loaf years ago, I actually walked out of a lecture because the speaker was so disdainful of pleasure. It wasn’t just that—in a lecture on brevity and concision and precision—he repeated himself endlessly or that he conflated the ideas of brevity and authenticity and immediacy. It wasn’t just that he had two hundred people waiting for wisdom and couldn’t keep his place, couldn’t remember quotes. It wasn’t just that he had no sense of situation, that he didn’t feel a need to command our attention with worthy focus.

Beyond all of that, beyond his multi-modal ineptness, his most damning critique for a story was that it was “workmanlike craft.” His melodrama led him to love lines like “Every book is an aborted suicide note,” led him to love diaries of men dying of tertiary syphilis.

Friends, my books are frivolous in the best possible way. They’re not aborted suicide notes; they’re acts of hospitality, self-aware that they will dissolve into mood rather than be held in specificity. They are, to use the words of David Littlejohn, “an hour more pleasingly crafted than everyday life.”

More on frivolity tomorrow.