Frivolous, High and Low

Just this patio and pool cost more than a year’s wages for the entire staff of your local supermarket. Just sayin’… (Image by Simon Tartarotti, via Unsplash)

One of the great things about having smart friends is that they have smart ideas no matter what you’re talking about. My friend Nick was over to play pool last night (he’s very good), and I was telling him the premise of Jehanne Dubrow’s book Frivolity that I’ve been discussing here for the past few days. He locked in on the idea pretty quickly, nodding and amplifying, and then said, “I don’t really think anything is frivolous unless rich people do it.” Our subsequent conversation was about scarcity of resources, both time and money, for most of us. The decision to apply some of that scarcity to a pleasure, to move however briefly beyond necessity to frivolity, is a proportionally more important statement. When Jeff Bezos buys a $500 million mega-yacht, that represents one tenth of one percent of his net worth. The median net worth of an American family is $216,000, so $216 would be an equivalent proportion.

Let’s take a specific example that I know well. Growing up in the midwest, I held Viking pool cues as a magical brand, one of the very first cue makers to apply custom techniques to more broadly affordable cues. They’ve since been joined by dozens of others, but Viking is still a romanticized name for me. So the first really good cue I ever bought was a Viking. Here are two of their current line.

This is the Viking B2605. Stained maple body, clear maple shaft, linen wrap, laminated leather tip. Just under $400, and it’ll do anything you need. It’s a good cue, far more competent than most of the players who’ll ever hold it.

This is the Viking Heirloom TF-4C. Stained maple body, clear maple shaft, laminated leather tip. $2,700. It’s functionally the same cue as the B2605, but costs almost seven times more, because of the maple, ebony, and turquoise inlay work. Four hundred bucks gets you a high-performance cue: the other $2,300 is frivolous. Viking makes more or less the same cue in a hundred different models, with prices from $400 to $4,000. Every player decides which design suits their personalities, how to represent themselves when they come to the table.


Dubrow’s book doesn’t deal with working-class frivolity. As a child from an academic and diplomatic family, she’s lived at a remove from pool cues and pickup trucks, from Christmas lights strung up around the ranch-house porch and inflatable lawn ornaments. For her, “frivolity” is a category encompassing makeup and perfume, fashion and opera, Roy Lichetenstein and John Singer Sargent. As a poet, she’s dedicated her entire working life to frivolityโ€”you can’t eat a poem, it won’t pull your car out of the mud.

The word I think I’m searching for, in regards to working-class frivolity, is kitsch. It’s a term drawn from the art markets of 19th Century Germany to refer to art that was “cheap, popular, and marketable.” It’s a term only ever used in a pejorative sense, applied to popular sentiment by those of greater refinement. According to literary philosopher Winfried Menninghaus, “Kitsch offers instantaneous emotional gratification without intellectual effort, without the requirement of distance, without sublimation. It usually presents no difficulties in interpretation and has absolutely nothing to do with an aesthetics of negativity. It is unadulterated beauty, a simple invitation to wallow in sentiment…”, a definition from which he goes on to talk about Teodoro Adorno blah blah blah.

You’ll remember from the last couple of days about the work that the word “mere” does in the formulations “mere pleasure” and “mere entertainment.” Look here at the similar work being done by “gratification without intellectual effort,” or by “wallow in sentiment.” Apparently, kitsch is frivolity as consumed by the stupid and lazy.

Let’s skip the news boy (I’ll make some tea)
The Arabs and the Jews boy (too much for me)
They get me confused boy (puts me off to sleep)
And the thing I hate – Oh Lord!
Is staying up late, to watch some debate, on some nation’s fate.

“Blood on the Rooftops,” Genesis, Wind and Wuthering.

As a class traitor, I can make fun of kitsch as well as anybody else, but I do have some lived understanding of what it’s doing for people. Following on Dubrow, kitschy art and junk food are affordable and accessible means to say that life isn’t just labor, isn’t just responsibilities. It’s a way, momentarily, to lift one’s head above water, to claim a sliver of autonomy and pleasure. “The modest macaroon tastes like rebellion,” she writes about Ibsen’s A Doll’s House. “Eating a cookie is her miniature act of insurrection. Each time she bites into another macaroon, Nora chews at the gritty constraints of her life: Torvald and his nagging control, her lack of financial freedom, the confinement of domesticity.” (pp.77-78) Doritos and Mountain Dew and Bud Light do the same work today, addressing the same motives, but they’re not as fancy as macaroons, aren’t mentioned by Ibsen.

Moreโ€”and more personalโ€”tomorrow.

Frivolous

Frivolous, but maybe in a different way than she means it.
(Image by Filip Mroz, via Unsplash)

We began a couple of days ago with a consideration of Jehanne Dubrow’s new book Frivolity: a Defense. I’ll continue, but like her, I want to highlight one particular issue of writing strategy before I begin. The book exists in the world; it is a physical object for sale. It has been published by a reputable house, and it went through a review process along the way. I have no justification for saying whether it is or is not “good.” The only thing I can do honestly is to point out places where I stumbled along the read, and to equally point out moments where I sat and said “I hadn’t thought of that.” Criticism, for me, is first-person singular.


Her own writing strategy is that she’s organized the book as 101… small essays? Stanzas? Item 26 says this:

What if I were to write a defense of frivolity? What if I composed it as a list of perplexities? Because our lives are unbearably torn, I would say. Because we need diversion. Because pleasure. Because paradox. (p.20)

So let’s begin with my first stumble, which happens pretty early on, in perplexity #6. She’s laid out the argument she’ll make: Things which are frivolous are deemed unworthy of serious attention (frivolous and serious being almost an etymological distinction, antonyms in any good dictionary). They are deemed so at least in part because they’re read as being feminine and being queer, concerned with surfaces rather than essences. So the opening of perplexity 6 reads:

Feminine, because items deemed frivolousโ€”let’s say a lipstick shaped like a sleek, red bullet of seductionโ€”are mostly marketed and sold to women. Men’s passions are taken seriously. The games they play as children become their weekend hobbies as adults, even if now they only watch a ball being hurled back and forth from the marshmallow cushions of their living rooms. Men are permitted to be fans. They can wear jerseys that hang to their knees, baggy shorts in primary colors, without censure. and the game (whatever that might be) is never a frivolity.

But a woman who buys a bottle of perfume must be condemned for spending money on a silly spritz of mimosa and patchouli. She is judged for wanting what women want. Purses and heels. A dress made of something silly called charmeuse, a French words that means a woman who charms, one who bewitches. (pp.3-4)

It seems an implied contrast is being written here, between frivolous/women and hobby/men. This is a contrast I don’t understand, and to explain that, let’s look at the photo at the top of this piece again.

The truck is a lovingly restored and modified mid-1960s Ford F-100. (Think about that. It’s sixty years old! Who would voluntarily drive a sixty-year-old car?) It was originally made for entirely serious purposes: trips to the lumberyard, a job-site toolbox, a hauler of concrete and hay bales. But everything that has been done to it here is frivolous. The perfectly-sprayed lime green paint. The Mad Max bumper with its push bars and tow links. The foot-and-a-half suspension lift, paired with tires that can’t possibly fit within any knowable wheel wells. This manโ€”and we have to assume this is owned and built by a manโ€”could have walked into a Ford dealership and bought a 2026 F-150 XLT for $45,000, with the extended cab, air conditioning, 430HP engine, air bags and touch screen, USB ports and cup holders everywhere. But this man chose instead to spend more than that to have a different kind of experience. This truck is a folly, impossible to navigate in any parking lot or city street, an active hazard to everyone around it. And yet, it is an object of veneration and craft for those who value it.

It seems to me that all hobbies are frivolous. Although Dubrow places sports into a different category than lipstick, there is nothing more frivolous than adult men and women attempting to throw a round leather sphere through an orange iron ring. It accomplishes nothing of worth. It is mere (that damning word) entertainment. To use her own language, basketball exists “Because we need diversion. Because pleasure.”

If we are going to defend a principle, whether frivolity or free speech or any other, we have to defend individual instances that we find distasteful. A defense of lipstick must also be a defense of lifted trucks. A defense of perfume must also be a defense of football. A defense of a pastry must also be a defense of an airbrushed t-shirt bought at the county fair. To defend the idea of the unnecessary is to defend its expressions.


It seems to me that a better definition of the frivolous includes all acts that are taken seriously by those who engage in them, and disdained or demeaned by those on the outside. This blog itself is frivolous; it feeds no one, it generates no income. It isn’t an urgent analysis of current events or public policy. It is a trifle, a gift first to myself and then to any others who might find it enjoyable (the identityโ€”or even the existenceโ€”of whom I can’t possibly know).

The work of Hannah Arendt’s animal laborans and homo faber are easily understood as the work of necessity and sustenance; the work of the vita activa, life among and for others, is endlessly debatable. Why would anybody bother doing that? we ask, whether the “that” is playing pool or cheerleading or spending a thousand dollars a head at a Michelin-starred restaurant. Those outside see no value; those inside, exercising connoisseurship, understand the nuances that transport category into specific.

And here we get into questions of taste, and therefore of class. More tomorrow.

Misfit Container

Sometimes there’s just more than can be contained.
(image by Ephraim Mayrena, via Unsplash)

I just finished a book that I wanted to like more than I did. I’ll have more to say about it over the next few days, so obviously it made me think, but maybe not exactly about what the author hoped I’d think about.

The book in question is Frivolity: A Defense, by Jehanne Dubrow. I was drawn to it because my writer friends are so, so serious (Hilton Als recently wrote about much of contemporary art as “grief porn”), and all I want to do is give people a good story that leaves them with something to think about afterwards. I think about writing a novel as being in the same category as making my friends a nice dinner, an analogy that infuriates one of my colleagues. So I wanted to read something that acknowledged the value of work that doesn’t see itself in conversation with a canon. (My canon, if I have one, is composed of paperback novels and TV sitcoms.)

I’ll talk more about the ideas of the book tomorrow. For today, I want to write about its most heartbreaking passage. I’d finished the book, and was browsing through its end matter. The Acknowlegements, the Notes, the Bibliography, the Indexโ€”all of the academic armor that turns a 119-page book into a 144-page book, that allows its publication by a university press, that gives its author further hold on the sheer walls of academia. The kind of stuff you’d never find in a novel, the kind of stuff that marks a book as “one of ours” if that’s the crowd you run with.

And the very last endnote, note 156 that clings to the final punctuation mark of the text, ends with this:

So, I’ll confess: If I could give myself a name, it might not be scholar. It might be epicure or enthusiast. It might be lover instead.

Ms. Dubrow, or perhaps more appropriately Dr. Dubrow, has found a container for her work that doesn’t actually hold the entirety of her work. She must be a Distinguished Research Professor, not an enthusiast. She works within an academic context that actively demeans frivolity, a context that demands “rigor” and “advancement of the discipline” and looks at pleasure (“mere” pleasure) with suspicion.

When I was at Bread Loaf years ago, I actually walked out of a lecture because the speaker was so disdainful of pleasure. It wasnโ€™t just thatโ€”in a lecture on brevity and concision and precisionโ€”he repeated himself endlessly or that he conflated the ideas of brevity and authenticity and immediacy. It wasnโ€™t just that he had two hundred people waiting for wisdom and couldnโ€™t keep his place, couldnโ€™t remember quotes. It wasnโ€™t just that he had no sense of situation, that he didnโ€™t feel a need to command our attention with worthy focus.

Beyond all of that, beyond his multi-modal ineptness, his most damning critique for a story was that it was โ€œworkmanlike craft.โ€ His melodrama led him to love lines like โ€œEvery book is an aborted suicide note,โ€ led him to love diaries of men dying of tertiary syphilis.

Friends, my books are frivolous in the best possible way. They’re not aborted suicide notes; they’re acts of hospitality, self-aware that they will dissolve into mood rather than be held in specificity. They are, to use the words of David Littlejohn, “an hour more pleasingly crafted than everyday life.”

More on frivolity tomorrow.

168

All this for only ten minutes? Why, thank you!
(Photo byย Giorgio Trovatoย onย Unsplash)

One of the quick responses to our resistance to wealth inequality is that we don’t want to disincentivize hard work. Why shouldn’t someone who works hard get rich?

Well, I think that they should. The question is what we mean by works hard, and by rich.

For example, let’s take our road foreman. Responsible for the safety and accessibility of a town of 800, supervising the condition of 35 miles of mostly gravel road. He holds a commercial driver’s license, so he’s allowed to drive massive trucks on public roads. He can also operate a grader, a loader, a mid-sized excavator, a backhoe. He can do fundamental maintenance and repair on each. He knows how to plow, how to repair mud-sinks, how to replace culverts, how to drain water. He wrestles plow assemblies up onto frames, chops frozen salt-sand mix before it clogs the sander, sprays calcium chloride onto dusty roads in the summer. He knows how to buy and install road fabric, how to specify grades of gravel, when to call in reinforcements for heavy storms.

He works hard. He isn’t rich.


Here’s how I think about it. There are exactly 168 hours in everyone’s week, whether you’re an infant or an elder, whether you’re homeless or a tycoon. Let’s look at what happens at different hourly wages.

  • 40 hours at $15 an hour: $600 a week, $30,000 a year
  • 40 hours at $150 an hour: $6,000 a week, $300,000 a year
  • 40 hours at $1,500 an hour: $60,000 a week, $3,000,000 a year

That seems rich, don’t you think? But let’s say that we aren’t talking about 40 hour weeks, let’s say that our miracle CEO never sleeps and never takes a minute to rest. At $1,500 an hour and 168 hours for 52 weeks, he or she would make $13,104,000 for a year of continuous toil.

At that rate, it would take this person over 76 years to become a billionaire if they never spent a penny of it.

There comes a scale at which money no longer comes from work. It comes from the work of others. It comes from the ways that others have made bets with it, or on it. It comes from political influence. It comes from everywhere OTHER THAN hard work.

As I read last week, “record profits” is just a synonym for “low wages.” The paradox of “rewarding hard work” is that oligarchs become and remain so by ensuring that hard work isn’t well rewarded, that benefits flow upward rather than outward. Who works harder than our road foreman? Who works harder than an ER nurse, than a kindergarten teacher, than a McDonalds line cook at lunch rush?

It’s time for not merely a minimum wage, but a maximum as well. Reward hard work, regardless of what it looks like, instead of the logic of the casino and the grifter.

Purring

Your friend and mine

Soft kitty, warm kitty,

little ball of fur

Happy kitty, sleepy kitty

purr purr purr

We had quite a shock over the last week. Our cat Emily had had a sinus virus, and we brought her in for an antibiotic. Our vet opened her mouth and saw that her entire upper left jaw was infected, and that the teeth were loose. He gave her three days of heavy antibiotic injection, and we brought her on Saturday for a surgery.

It turned out that she had a tumor in her sinus that had already dissolved much of the maxilla. She could have come home with us โ€” Bruce estimated that we’d have about a week โ€” but she wouldn’t have been able to eat, her gums wouldn’t have healed, and she’d likely have been miserable. So we went in on Saturday evening for that most unfortunate act of love, deciding that the end has come.

Bruce brought her in; she was alert and comfortable. And as we petted her and talked to her, she rolled onto her side to get a belly pet, and went into her reliable, loud, fully absorbed purring. She knew that she was loved, and that we protected her. And that’s all we can ask of anyone.


I think that purring is an underrated aspiration for the artist. Comfortable people can afford to be made uncomfortable by their art; intellectual disturbance is a luxury that sits way up at the top of the pyramid of needs. The entire history of architecture since Corbusier has been all head and no heart, practiced and studied by people for whom rigor is the utmost human value. (Don’t get me wrongโ€”there’s plenty of good and humane architecture. We just don’t teach it or praise it.)

I write because I need occasionally to purr. Because I need to tell myself a story in which, no matter how much bullshit we have to navigate, no matter how many stupid or malicious people we encounter along the way, it’s gonna be okay. It’s all gonna be okay. And then I give it to friends, and I hope they’ll purr as well.

This is my message to young writers (and to married people, and to parents…). Evoking comfort is not a goal that will win you a seat in an MFA program, or publication in the (deservedly) little magazines. But it’s a worthy goal nonetheless.

If you value purring, work to make it happen. Those who trust you will know it’s all gonna be okay.

Happy Birthday

A certain beauty comes with decay.
(image by Viktor Hesse, via Unsplash)

I took the dog for a late walk this evening around 10, and listened to the array of explosions all around. They were coming from six or eight unique locations, a couple of bangs at a time from one direction followed by half a minute’s silence and then a couple from somewhere else. At one point, I heard the distinctive, rhythmic pop-pop-pop-pop of a semiautomatic rifle (living in the country, you learn what that is just like you can hear the difference between a gasoline and a diesel truck). Twenty bullets spent in eight seconds, and god help whoever’s down-range.

Nothing collective. Nothing aesthetic. Just a bunch of isolated folks winding down their thirty-racks of Coors Light by participating in our national pastime of blowing things up.

It was a fitting conclusion to a week of collapse at the Great American State Fair, a birthday festival in which nothing worked, classical architecture made of canvas fluttered against its metal-pipe frame, scaffolding fell down behind the performers, and there was a lot more grass than there were people standing on it. The neo-Nazis put on the best-organized parade in DC.

After 45 years of letting the wealthy strip all the rivets and brackets and fittings that hold the nation together, it can’t come as much of a surprise when one particularly gifted dumbass gives it a shove and the whole thing collapses. That sound you’re hearing may not be fireworks at all; it might be the last structural members giving way.

The Hustle

In training to be your waiter.
(Image by Yogendra Singh, via Unslpash)

Back in 1990, I was a grading assistant for Paul Groth’s course in American vernacular architecture. As the junior member of the teaching team, I was sent downstairs to get fancy coffees for the rest of the team and myself. When I came back up the stairs, I had the cardboard cup tray on the palm of one hand, and distributed cups to friends with the other. Paul noticed that, and complimented me on my skill. I said that I’d spent a little time as a waiter. And Paul, who was gay and lived in San Francisco, took a beat, and then said, “In my community, waiters have to be gorgeous.”

We all know that every upscale restaurant in Los Angeles and New York employs a wait staff made up of aspiring performers who rely equally on talent and on physical beauty . You can still encounter a normal human at a neighborhood taco shack, but if you have to make a reservation, you’ll be waited on by a perfect specimen.

I was at an event recently at which one of the guests was a professional party organizer, employed to put on bridal showers and lawn gatherings for wealthy families. She told us of one such party in which she and her team were selecting “cater-waiters” from a portfolio provided by a modeling agency. They had requested both clothed and shirtless photos of all of the men they were browsing, quickly sorting into piles of acceptable and unacceptable based on the character of their abdominal muscles rather than food knowledge or service experience.

The family’s criteria for service staff had been explicit and simple, she said. No Uglies.


“The hustle” has become a defining work mode of our time. Everything is done with an eye to how it moves you forward. And it has a lot in common with drowning, grasping in desperation at any passing branch, hoping it’ll keep you afloat a little longer. When stability and security aren’t available, you need to have your eyes in motion and grab whatever feed presents itself.

About the time I was working for Paul at Berkeley, the sociologist Hugh Klein published one of the most influential articles I’ve ever read โ€” “Adolescence, Youth, and Young Adulthood:ย Rethinking Current Conceptualizations of Life Stage.” (Youth & Society, 21:4, June 1990) His argument was simple: that we conflate culture with nature, and so presume that stages of life like “children” and “teenagers” and “retirees” are biological facts. Age is certainly a biological fact, but the social roles that a five-year-old would be expected to fulfill have varied enormously across history and place.

Klein focused his research specifically on the stages of life that we’ve created to describe people between 14 and 25 or so. There weren’t really any teenagers until compulsory high school education created them; there weren’t really any young adults until college became such a ubiquitous experience that we had to call those people something. 1 So in light of our current economy โ€” in which pick-up work is often all that’s available, influencers are dense as dandelions, and Patreon and OnlyFans and Substack offer the chance to make a living one subscriber at a timeโ€”I’ll propose a stage of life between 25 and 35, specific to contemporary American life, that I’ll call the Hustlers.

I think that by the time you’re a few years out of college, you’ve started to realize a fact that’s both unspoken and irrefutableโ€”that the boundary between prodigy and has-been is sudden, sharp, and unpredictable. That with no warning, and by someone else’s decision, you might find yourself on the wrong side of the fence. That you might find yourself left out of the cater-waiter portfolio, that the arc of your trajectory has apexed out. There’s an increased awareness that the clock is running and there’s a deadline.

You’d better hustle.

  1. Endless intellectual nonsense has been generated because of the unwarranted generalizations of Neil Howe and William Strauss, who codified the idea of Gen X and Millennials and all that crap. Their work lives in the same general neighborhood as astrology. โ†ฉ๏ธŽ

Proxy for the Unlived

Storytelling.
Image by Sandy Millar, via Unsplash

I was having my weekly coffee with a friend this morning, who’d recently finished reading my book & Sons. He had another commitment to get away to, but he asked if we could talk about the book next week. And he asked a question I’ve never been asked before: “How would you like to talk about it?”

Having been in lots of situations where a group of people were talking about what I’d written, I can tell you that the same handful of questions and comments come up over and over.

  • How do you know so much about (plow truck driving, table tennis, being in a big band…)?
  • I really liked it! (Usually followed by the recounting of one particular scene that stuck out to them.)
  • I know someone like that, or we’re going through something similar right now…
  • It would be better if (followed by some major restructuring that completely negates my work as a writer, and takes agency for themselves)
  • There’s a typo on page 187.

So, if not just those, how WOULD I like to talk about it?

Well, the surrounding conversation was about letting go of imagined futures, about those richly imagined stories we’d once built about who we were bound to be. Stories in which we had become professional baseball players, or musicians, or college faculty members. When those mirages inevitably vanish, I think we don’t do enough work to acknowledge our grief. And what is grief, really, but coming to terms with a new future that doesn’t include the old one? We grieve our partners, because our own future doesn’t include them. We grieve our pets, because our own future doesn’t include them. And I think it makes sense to grieve our truncated dreams, whatever they were, when our own future doesn’t include them

That’s what my best writing does.


I shared a story with my writing group a year or so ago, and they reiterated their core complaint with my work, which is that the characters don’t have enough bad things happen to them. They subscribe to the aphorism (of unclear origin) that the writer’s job is to get the protagonists up into a tree and then throw rocks at them.

I’m not interested in hostility as the basis for writing, and I’ve talked a lot about that in this space. But they followed that recommendation with the idea that this story felt to them like “wish fulfillment.”

Close, but no.

I think, in the work that feels closest and most successful, I’ve played out one of my lapsed selves, as realistically as I know how to do. That means knowing its disappointments and disillusionment as well as its successes and pleasures. I’ve been able to be a professional table tennis player, and to know how much of the rest of life I wasn’t able to taste because of the singular focus required to be that good. I’ve gotten to be a college faculty member, gotten to be tall and attractive, gotten to be a professional musician, and I’ve learned those lives well enough to NOT have them be merely rainbow-pony wish fulfillment.

I’ve done the same thing on behalf of others. I wrote a book in which my mother had some of the life she never got to have, and felt what it meant to have her success be both powerful and anonymous. I wrote a book in which our local road foreman got some of the respect and resources he’s deserved, while still acknowledging how brutal the work is.

Wanting those other lives so badly, on behalf of myself and others, is what made them worth writing about. It’s what’s lifted those stories beyond the realm of their instigating ideas, and made them fully inhabited. That’s not wish fulfillment. It’s a form of grief, allowing the lapsed dreams to be realized so fully that I can finally let them go.

โ€œWriting to me is an advanced and slow form of reading. If you find a book you really want to read but it hasnโ€™t been written yet, then you must write it.โ€ This statement, spoken by Toni Morrison in 1981, is the basis of my writing. No one else has written about the lives I’ve lost, so I guess I have to do it myself.

Belated Followthrough

A particular attitude toward the work. (Cover of 500 Cabinets (Lark Press, 2010), a book by Ray Hemachandra and John Grew Sheridan. This featured cabinet is “Yin, Yang, and Young,” by Steven M. White, 2006.)

Okay, I know I left off my last post with “more again tomorrow,” but things have intervened. I’ll have more to say about that further below. For now, let’s get back to the work of failing to measure up.

Part of what it means to produce “work of quality” is to locate the work accurately within the conversation it wants to be part of. An IKEA cabinet is a work of quality in important ways: it’s accessible in cost and construction to millions of users, and it uses stable, veneered plywood rather than expensive and ever-moving birch hardwood. It’s true to its Scandinavian Modern origins. And it holds things out of the way of dust and dog slobber. All good.

Steven White’s cabinet in the image above is also a work of quality. The joinery is exquisite, each joint cut to its specific location along its curve. (Try to make a curved drawer. I dare you.) The design idea carries through in smart ways: the button knobs curving up the (sometimes implied) centerline of the curved case, the two paired side cabinets providing the front legs while the taller back cabinet provides the back legs. The light wood of the side doors and the dark buttons balancing the uniformity of the cherry body. And the whole thing looks like Fantasia, bewitched furniture becoming animated. This is a person who’s studied not merely cabinetry but also art history, and understands what contrapposto is.

It’s almost certainly wildly expensive, because of its innumerable hand-cut joints. And although it protects its belongings from dust and dog slobber, you can’t just throw your wallet on the top when you go to bed, because it’ll slide off.

Which is the “better cabinet?” That depends entirely on what conversation it wants to enter.

I ran face first into this question, which I’d never considered before, when I went to architecture school and entered studio. These were artists who had no interest in whether you could toss your wallet on top of the dresser. Whether someone could care for a sick child or have a dozen friends over for cocktails. Had no interest in the relationship between bathroom and bedroom. I didn’t know it at the time, but they were trying to break us, like wild horses made tame. To unlearn everything we’d ever known about houses and stores, about streets and neighborhoods; to erase all of that vernacular wisdom and enter the world of studio art.

The work we were to emulate was wildly expensive, just as unique in execution as that cabinet. It mostly didn’t have to respond to any programmatic requirements, being instead an exhibition pavilion or a vacation house or simply a drawn idea. We were asked to enter a new conversation, one for which I at least had no vocabulary nor native interest.


Lots of fields have this division. Publishing clearly differentiates between “literary fiction,” in which questions of language and form are central, and “commercial fiction” that emphasizes pageturnability and adherence to genre norms. Literary fiction is scarce and resource-intensive, which is why so many of its practitioners are employed by universities whose patronage applauds the publication of one moderately-selling book every few years. Commercial fiction and its authors rely on reliably sufficient book sales in order to survive, and thus engage in a different conversation.

Popular music, folk music and “serious” music. Dirt-track racing, NASCAR and Formula 1. Different conversations within the same general category, and thus judged by different criteria. I remember going around the table at our first Bread Loaf meeting, where we were all asked to name a few favorite writers. Mostly I hadn’t heard of any of them, even as the others all muttered after each name with that hushed “mmm” of connoisseurship. I named Walter Tevis (a highly successful commercial writer) and Rex Stout, the author of a forty-year mystery series. And I could feel the pity of the serious writers, wondering how a person of such diminished judgment could ever have been allowed through the literary gates.


So that brings me to the work that’s kept me away for a week. My new play “Old Dogs on the Porch” is having its world premier this Friday, and will run for the next two weeks on Friday, Saturday and Sunday. If you’re in New England, I think it’s worth the trip. Tickets are available here.

This week has been the work of installing the set, getting the sound and lights right, and having the cast become accustomed to doing their work in a designed space rather than around folding chairs and through implied doorways. There are about twenty people who’ve been involved in bringing this production to life, and I’m grateful to each one. I hope to see you if you’re able. And we can have a conversation.

Immeasurable

The best there is… if that’s what you want.
(Image by Samuel Ramos, via Unsplash)

So yesterday, I used my lapsed bowling career as an example of the distance between people who are merely reallyreallyreally good and people who are at the peak of whatever endeavor they’ve chosen. I think, in principle, that the same general logarithmic distance is true in whatever field of practice we might consider. Every step is a mile, and there are a lot of steps to take.

But bowling is limited in its utility as a model, because it’s objective. Scores are scores, tournaments are won and recorded, and there’s no argument about intentions or values. There are lots of endeavors in which we might excel in ways that aren’t as easy to know, or to agree upon.


I’m enough of an elitist to resent being labeled a “local author.” But certainly the objective record of my fiction writing is exactly that. I’ve not had fiction published, by a major house or a minor indie. I do it because it’s a meditative act, because the craft matters. Using language to render complicated lives in complicated circumstances… there’s nothing that absorbs me more fully.

But if that’s my motivation, why would I inflict the outcomes upon others? Why not just leave it on the hard drive? That’s the point at which the questions of relative quality emerge. Is it good enough to share? Am I proud of it? Will the person I’m sharing it with enjoy it? Will they TELL ME they enjoyed it? It’s just an ugly smoothie blended from mixed ingredients: vanity and generosity, validation and hope.

One of the thoughts I’ve shared with my writing group a few times is that for me, giving someone one of my books is like making them a meal. I just want them to have a nice evening, and I have enough confidence that my cooking matches their tastes to make the offer. And ohhhh, does one of my colleagues hate that idea! It demeans the craft, it doesn’t take the work seriously. He’s also said that he’s terrified of dying, though, and I think he wants something to live on when he’s gone.

I don’t, oddly enough. When I’m dead, everything I ever could have done, generous or otherwise, will be done. The rest will be compost. So because I’m not in the game of “legacy,” I have a little less interest in comparing quality. It’s as good as I know how to make it.

What I need is to be acknowledged, by an audience larger than my friends and neighbors. And that’s a sad fact to sit with.


The Dunning-Kruger effect comes into play here as well. When I was a Level Three bowler, I thought I was going to be a professional. Once I got to Level Five, I recognized that I wouldn’t. Not because I’d stopped trying or gotten lazy, but because I knew so much more that I could appreciate how much broader the chasm was that lie ahead. The more you know about something, the more you know you don’t know. The less you know about something, the easier it seems. I mean, everybody can write, right? Everybody can sing, everybody can drive a car and ride a bike. Being a professional at those things must just mean doing more of it.

You have to go a long, long way down the road to realize how vast and complicated the road is. And by that time, you’ve dedicated most of your young life to the journey. The craft matters to you, you’ve given yourself to it and received so much beauty in return. But there will come a moment when you realize that you will never be Simone Biles, or LeBron James, or Yo-Yo Ma, or Lewis Hamilton, or Emma Stone. There will come a moment when you realize that your ticket won’t take you to the final station, that you’ll disembark in some one-dog town along the way.

More again tomorrow.