
One of the great things about having smart friends is that they have smart ideas no matter what you’re talking about. My friend Nick was over to play pool last night (he’s very good), and I was telling him the premise of Jehanne Dubrow’s book Frivolity that I’ve been discussing here for the past few days. He locked in on the idea pretty quickly, nodding and amplifying, and then said, “I don’t really think anything is frivolous unless rich people do it.” Our subsequent conversation was about scarcity of resources, both time and money, for most of us. The decision to apply some of that scarcity to a pleasure, to move however briefly beyond necessity to frivolity, is a proportionally more important statement. When Jeff Bezos buys a $500 million mega-yacht, that represents one tenth of one percent of his net worth. The median net worth of an American family is $216,000, so $216 would be an equivalent proportion.
Let’s take a specific example that I know well. Growing up in the midwest, I held Viking pool cues as a magical brand, one of the very first cue makers to apply custom techniques to more broadly affordable cues. They’ve since been joined by dozens of others, but Viking is still a romanticized name for me. So the first really good cue I ever bought was a Viking. Here are two of their current line.

This is the Viking B2605. Stained maple body, clear maple shaft, linen wrap, laminated leather tip. Just under $400, and it’ll do anything you need. It’s a good cue, far more competent than most of the players who’ll ever hold it.

This is the Viking Heirloom TF-4C. Stained maple body, clear maple shaft, laminated leather tip. $2,700. It’s functionally the same cue as the B2605, but costs almost seven times more, because of the maple, ebony, and turquoise inlay work. Four hundred bucks gets you a high-performance cue: the other $2,300 is frivolous. Viking makes more or less the same cue in a hundred different models, with prices from $400 to $4,000. Every player decides which design suits their personalities, how to represent themselves when they come to the table.
Dubrow’s book doesn’t deal with working-class frivolity. As a child from an academic and diplomatic family, she’s lived at a remove from pool cues and pickup trucks, from Christmas lights strung up around the ranch-house porch and inflatable lawn ornaments. For her, “frivolity” is a category encompassing makeup and perfume, fashion and opera, Roy Lichetenstein and John Singer Sargent. As a poet, she’s dedicated her entire working life to frivolityโyou can’t eat a poem, it won’t pull your car out of the mud.
The word I think I’m searching for, in regards to working-class frivolity, is kitsch. It’s a term drawn from the art markets of 19th Century Germany to refer to art that was “cheap, popular, and marketable.” It’s a term only ever used in a pejorative sense, applied to popular sentiment by those of greater refinement. According to literary philosopher Winfried Menninghaus, “Kitsch offers instantaneous emotional gratification without intellectual effort, without the requirement of distance, without sublimation. It usually presents no difficulties in interpretation and has absolutely nothing to do with an aesthetics of negativity. It is unadulterated beauty, a simple invitation to wallow in sentiment…”, a definition from which he goes on to talk about Teodoro Adorno blah blah blah.
You’ll remember from the last couple of days about the work that the word “mere” does in the formulations “mere pleasure” and “mere entertainment.” Look here at the similar work being done by “gratification without intellectual effort,” or by “wallow in sentiment.” Apparently, kitsch is frivolity as consumed by the stupid and lazy.
Let’s skip the news boy (I’ll make some tea)
The Arabs and the Jews boy (too much for me)
They get me confused boy (puts me off to sleep)
And the thing I hate – Oh Lord!
Is staying up late, to watch some debate, on some nation’s fate.“Blood on the Rooftops,” Genesis, Wind and Wuthering.
As a class traitor, I can make fun of kitsch as well as anybody else, but I do have some lived understanding of what it’s doing for people. Following on Dubrow, kitschy art and junk food are affordable and accessible means to say that life isn’t just labor, isn’t just responsibilities. It’s a way, momentarily, to lift one’s head above water, to claim a sliver of autonomy and pleasure. “The modest macaroon tastes like rebellion,” she writes about Ibsen’s A Doll’s House. “Eating a cookie is her miniature act of insurrection. Each time she bites into another macaroon, Nora chews at the gritty constraints of her life: Torvald and his nagging control, her lack of financial freedom, the confinement of domesticity.” (pp.77-78) Doritos and Mountain Dew and Bud Light do the same work today, addressing the same motives, but they’re not as fancy as macaroons, aren’t mentioned by Ibsen.
Moreโand more personalโtomorrow.











