
I strongly agree with Jehanne Dubrow (Frivolity: a Defense, the book under discussion for the last few days) that pleasure is, for many people, untrustworthy and intellectually dubious. In architecture, comfort is almost never discussed. When Billy Collins, one of America’s most approachable and beloved poets, was named the nation’s Poet Laureate, there was a strong backlash within the “serious” poetry community, some of whom went so far as to name an “antilaureate” for the two years of his term. Commercial fiction, lowbrow art, pop music, junk food… there are a lot of ways to indicate disapproval of work that doesn’t live up to the highest intellectual standards.
Academia in particular is a dour location, in which reading or writing for enjoyment is just wrong. We “interrogate” a text; we “grapple” with an idea. We read “orthogonally, with and against the grain.” If we actually enjoy something, we have to make the shift to irony, perching on our own shoulders to offer demeaning commentary. (Irony may be the most tragic form of pleasure, poisoning its own delights.)
Yesterday, I wrote about Dubrow’s discussion of A Doll’s House, and the character Nora’s use of macaroons to free herself momentarily from the material and emotional constraints of her life. I understand that intimately. I’m not brave enough to tell you the entire story, but I’ll tell you some.
I was a fat kid, raised by a fat mom. “Love” was spelled O-R-E-O. Short and unathletic and smart, I excelled in school, which gave me even more reason to stay indoors. (Almost every good thing in my life has happened indoors. Classrooms, conversations, sex, bowling, pool, table tennis, music, writing and reading… Outside, it’s just trees and rocks.)
When my first wife and I eloped, I discovered how easy it was to walk everywhere and never have to drive, never have to take a bus. She’d grown up walking and never stopped. We were broke, but walking and riding our bikes was free. I almost immediately lost fifty pounds, which allowed me to start running and cycling seriously, which dropped twenty more. We lived in Oakland, where running was easy all twelve months of the year, and we had our choice of races to run in every weekend. I was up to 40 miles a week, under 40 minutes for a 10K and under 19 for a 5K, a couple of valiant attempts at marathon distance. I wore 31-inch-waist pants.
My first marriage… I loved my wife, and I still do, twenty years later. But she came from a particular family of dour and sour, a line of northern prairie Lutherans, all superego and no id. Pleasures, whatever they were, came after all duties had been exercised; and since duties are endless, pleasures rarely arrived. Productive self-improvement was the order of the day.
I was an academic hero at Berkeley for my undergrad, and an academic hero all over again at UW–Milwaukee for my doctorate. I’d put in the work on both my body and my scholarship. But for the decade or so around and after my PhD, I learned that being fit didn’t make me sexually desirable, and being acknowledged academically didn’t make me faculty-desirable. The work hadn’t paid off, and never would. And I said “fuck it.” I ate badly, I drank too much beer, I actually started smoking at 41 (which I called “adult-onset stupidity). I knew that I would perpetually be denied the great pleasures I deserved, so I found myself unable to resist small pleasures. Each bag of chips or cigarette was, as Dubrow puts it, “a miniature act of insurrection:” an ineffective but necessary moment of agency to buffer a larger helplessness.
A few days ago, a friend sent me a link to Roger Rosenblatt’s essay “Thoughts near the end of a life” from the New York Times. (My apologies if you can’t get past the paywall; your library can get it for you, and you should read it.) One of the great elements of that essay is acknowledging the power of being a producer of pleasure and not merely a consumer.
There is a special kind of usefulness in the extension of empathy toward others, especially those who may feel deserted and alone. Every week or so, I write to one or another friend who recently lost a partner. The usefulness comes from making others feel worthy of your time and attention. In the cold isolations of modern life, to help them feel love or something akin to it.
It was said of Fyodor Dostoyevsky that he had active empathy. In older age one learns the value of that gift, which takes a lifetime to appreciate and apply. Maybe that is how one assesses progress in a life. To grow from self-interest to active empathy, which gives a certain peace.
In the anhedonic world, the only sin worse than enjoyment is the provision of pleasure to others. But I find myself in full agreement with Dubrow that frivolity is worthy and meaningful; the great (and unexpected) joy is that the act of producing it for others provides it to me as well. Pleasure created, pleasure enjoyed, a mutual gift.
Thanks to Dr. Dubrow for an important book, which did the work it was intended to do; it helped me think, which gave me pleasure.
