
(Image by Filip Mroz, via Unsplash)
We began a couple of days ago with a consideration of Jehanne Dubrow’s new book Frivolity: a Defense. I’ll continue, but like her, I want to highlight one particular issue of writing strategy before I begin. The book exists in the world; it is a physical object for sale. It has been published by a reputable house, and it went through a review process along the way. I have no justification for saying whether it is or is not “good.” The only thing I can do honestly is to point out places where I stumbled along the read, and to equally point out moments where I sat and said “I hadn’t thought of that.” Criticism, for me, is first-person singular.
Her own writing strategy is that she’s organized the book as 101… small essays? Stanzas? Item 26 says this:
What if I were to write a defense of frivolity? What if I composed it as a list of perplexities? Because our lives are unbearably torn, I would say. Because we need diversion. Because pleasure. Because paradox. (p.20)
So let’s begin with my first stumble, which happens pretty early on, in perplexity #6. She’s laid out the argument she’ll make: Things which are frivolous are deemed unworthy of serious attention (frivolous and serious being almost an etymological distinction, antonyms in any good dictionary). They are deemed so at least in part because they’re read as being feminine and being queer, concerned with surfaces rather than essences. So the opening of perplexity 6 reads:
Feminine, because items deemed frivolous—let’s say a lipstick shaped like a sleek, red bullet of seduction—are mostly marketed and sold to women. Men’s passions are taken seriously. The games they play as children become their weekend hobbies as adults, even if now they only watch a ball being hurled back and forth from the marshmallow cushions of their living rooms. Men are permitted to be fans. They can wear jerseys that hang to their knees, baggy shorts in primary colors, without censure. and the game (whatever that might be) is never a frivolity.
But a woman who buys a bottle of perfume must be condemned for spending money on a silly spritz of mimosa and patchouli. She is judged for wanting what women want. Purses and heels. A dress made of something silly called charmeuse, a French words that means a woman who charms, one who bewitches. (pp.3-4)
It seems an implied contrast is being written here, between frivolous/women and hobby/men. This is a contrast I don’t understand, and to explain that, let’s look at the photo at the top of this piece again.

The truck is a lovingly restored and modified mid-1960s Ford F-100. (Think about that. It’s sixty years old! Who would voluntarily drive a sixty-year-old car?) It was originally made for entirely serious purposes: trips to the lumberyard, a job-site toolbox, a hauler of concrete and hay bales. But everything that has been done to it here is frivolous. The perfectly-sprayed lime green paint. The Mad Max bumper with its push bars and tow links. The foot-and-a-half suspension lift, paired with tires that can’t possibly fit within any knowable wheel wells. This man—and we have to assume this is owned and built by a man—could have walked into a Ford dealership and bought a 2026 F-150 XLT for $45,000, with the extended cab, air conditioning, 430HP engine, air bags and touch screen, USB ports and cup holders everywhere. But this man chose instead to spend more than that to have a different kind of experience. This truck is a folly, impossible to navigate in any parking lot or city street, an active hazard to everyone around it. And yet, it is an object of veneration and craft for those who value it.
It seems to me that all hobbies are frivolous. Although Dubrow places sports into a different category than lipstick, there is nothing more frivolous than adult men and women attempting to throw a round leather sphere through an orange iron ring. It accomplishes nothing of worth. It is mere (that damning word) entertainment. To use her own language, basketball exists “Because we need diversion. Because pleasure.”
If we are going to defend a principle, whether frivolity or free speech or any other, we have to defend individual instances that we find distasteful. A defense of lipstick must also be a defense of lifted trucks. A defense of perfume must also be a defense of football. A defense of a pastry must also be a defense of an airbrushed t-shirt bought at the county fair. To defend the idea of the unnecessary is to defend its expressions.
It seems to me that a better definition of the frivolous includes all acts that are taken seriously by those who engage in them, and disdained or demeaned by those on the outside. This blog itself is frivolous; it feeds no one, it generates no income. It isn’t an urgent analysis of current events or public policy. It is a trifle, a gift first to myself and then to any others who might find it enjoyable (the identity—or even the existence—of whom I can’t possibly know).
The work of Hannah Arendt’s animal laborans and homo faber are easily understood as the work of necessity and sustenance; the work of the vita activa, life among and for others, is endlessly debatable. Why would anybody bother doing that? we ask, whether the “that” is playing pool or cheerleading or spending a thousand dollars a head at a Michelin-starred restaurant. Those outside see no value; those inside, exercising connoisseurship, understand the nuances that transport category into specific.
And here we get into questions of taste, and therefore of class. More tomorrow.
